AuctionBytes Blog
Covering auctions, collectibles and marketplace selling.

AuctionBytes Blog The AuctionBytes Blog has been giving a voice to online merchants since its launch in 2005. Named one of the world's top 30 blogs in 2008 by "Blogging Heroes." Weigh in with your thoughts on the joys and pitfalls of selling online.
Wed July 15 2026 10:52:53

Would a Stripe-Owned PayPal Be Good for Sellers?

By: Ina Steiner

Sponsored Link

CNBC reported on Wednesday that it had confirmed B2B payments firm Stripe - and private equity firm Advent International - have made a joint offer to buy PayPal in a deal valued at $53.4 billion.

According to Quartz, PayPal has been "navigating a prolonged turnaround after years of slowing growth and intensifying competition from rivals including Apple Pay and Google Pay." It said if completed, the acquisition would rank "among the largest in the payments sector in recent years."

Carl Icahn had forced eBay to break up PayPal in 2015 (which it had acquired in 2002), and in 2019, eBay changed from forcing sellers to use PayPal almost exclusively on its marketplace to taking over payment-processing itself through "Managed Payments." 

Buyers can still use PayPal when paying for their purchases on eBay (and other marketplaces). The risk for sellers is if new owners were to raise PayPal fees and/or use "slash and burn" tactics favored by private equity firms - potentially making PayPal less popular with buyers if cost-cutting were to go too far.

thread on Reddit from last year shows how sellers think about Stripe versus PayPal when setting up payments on their own websites. The original poster was choosing between the two payment processors for their new business and was seeking advice on which one was best. "Stripe looks super clean and customizable, but PayPal has the trust factor and is familiar to almost every online shopper. I'm wondering which one actually performs better in practice for conversions and overall customer experience."

CNBC said PayPal has not responded to the offer, which would see Stripe and Advent jointly own the company and hold equal stakes, and it said PayPal, Stripe, and Advent International declined to comment on the report.



Comments (6) | Permalink

Readers Comments

Perminate Link for Would a Stripe-Owned PayPal Be Good for Sellers?   Would a Stripe-Owned PayPal Be Good for Sellers?

by: tuneseller425 This user has validated their user name.

Wed Jul 15 14:43:00 2026

Making PayPal less popular? At least in my case, that would be pretty difficult to do. I only use PayPal when I absolutely must, like on marketplaces that don't allow other payment options, or as a buyer when a seller accepts only PayPal.  But honestly, in many cases, if a seller only accepts PayPal, I often don't make the purchase unless it's an absolute MUST have.  I didn't mind PayPal years ago, but they have changed.  They are fraudulent and have extraordinarily unreasonable legal agreements (for example, you are not guaranteed to get your order in the condition described if PayPal's automated system deems that it is intended for resale - and that system is NEVER wrong, according to PayPal).  Thanks, but I'll keep my money!

Perminate Link for Would a Stripe-Owned PayPal Be Good for Sellers?   Would a Stripe-Owned PayPal Be Good for Sellers?

This user has validated their user name. by: Rexford

Wed Jul 15 18:51:56 2026

I'd be ok with Stripe, but I'd give a big thumbs down to the private equity company.

Perminate Link for Would a Stripe-Owned PayPal Be Good for Sellers?   Would a Stripe-Owned PayPal Be Good for Sellers?

by: etectra This user has validated their user name.

Wed Jul 15 19:17:03 2026

" taking over payment-processing itself through "Managed Payments."

eBay does manage the payments at all. They are handled by Ayden, which eBay acquired 15% of by making Ayden their exclusive payment processor.

Before MP you would transfer payments to PayPal and then to your bank account where they would start earning interest within a few days. eBay fees were due on the 15th or last day of the month, which you then charge to your credit card and not have to pay for nearly another month. You would then earn typically 1, 1.5, or 2% of the amount charged back as rewards from the credit card. You could dispute expenses eBay is infamous for charging for services never ordered as well as double billing. MP was about raising prices and taking away your consumer rights.

Carl Ichan is said to have forced eBay to spin odd PayPal into a separate company in 2015. That same year he exchanged 46.3 million shares of eBay for PayPal stock. How smart is it to get rid of PayPal's exclusive deal with eBay and then acquire stock in PayPal? So how much other compensation from eBay did old Carl get for ushering in eBay raising prices and taking away consumer rights under the guide of spinning PayPal? The clear winner in the spin-off was eBay and not PayPal!

Perminate Link for Would a Stripe-Owned PayPal Be Good for Sellers?   Would a Stripe-Owned PayPal Be Good for Sellers?

by: etectra This user has validated their user name.

Wed Jul 15 19:19:56 2026

I would never accept PayPal or Stripe as I am not interested in giving away free merchandise and shipping.

I only accept Zelle.

I especially do not accept PayPal when one day they wanted a copy of a government i.d. despite the fact I have been using then since they were called X.Com and were giving away $5.00 to join.

Even my online banks do not have my government i.d.

Perminate Link for Would a Stripe-Owned PayPal Be Good for Sellers?   Would a Stripe-Owned PayPal Be Good for Sellers?

by: pace306 This user has validated their user name.

Thu Jul 16 20:23:39 2026

Why would ANY 3rd party payments co be worth that much ...?  What are they smoking?

Unlike eBay who went and (partially) bought into a bank - so they could only pay the fees V/M charged them was a smart move. They kicked Paypal to the curb and kept the extra % for themselves. Not telling anyone meant they didnt have to discount anything to sellers and could use that extra $ to report as income during any quarter they wanted to - to make it appear they were growing!  (nice con job there eBay - but some of us know your games)

What does Paypal bring to the table? When they were part of eBay - they did the processing because eBay could not/was not able to for a myriad of reasons. Also, it let eBay and Paypal bounce sellers back n forth ... playing good cop/bad cop at will. "See i would LOVE to give you back your funds but XXX (depending on whose turn it was) wont let!

Yes Icahn cut them loose - but that was because eBays reputation is/was SO BAD that Paypals association with them meant that no one else wanted to do business with them! I mean really, when you say I do business with eBay - people just laugh.

Now back to this ...Stripes gone no where, and trying to buy out Paypal wont help it become a player, at all. Mountains of debt after the buyout, little to no future growth meanst hey will BOTH go down in flames.

"PayPal has the trust factor and is familiar to almost every online shopper" .... it has a name (not trust) but no future.

Perminate Link for Would a Stripe-Owned PayPal Be Good for Sellers?   Would a Stripe-Owned PayPal Be Good for Sellers?

by: Geetar This user has validated their user name.

Sat Jul 18 08:57:05 2026

I have not used paypal in quite a long time. Probably years. I kind of scoffed at the idea that after the paypal / ebat split that paypal was valued higher than ebay. I kind of figured they would die a slow death. Honestly without ebay, they loose. Just the habit of using paypal because of ebay kept it afloat. Out of sight out of mind.



AB Verify login is required to post comments on the Blogs and EKG.
To sign in to leave a comment, fill in the form below. If you have not yet signed up for AB Verify, or if you'd like more information, go to the Registration Page
.

Posting comments in the News Section requires SEPARATE REGISTRATION.
Login for AB Verify
Be sure and use your email address and password to log in.

 
Email:
Password:
 
 Forgot Your Password?
 Even though you are signed in with the AuctionBytes Blog, you will have to sign in to the EcommerceBytes blog. But you can sign in with your existing AB Verify info.